Pubblicato in: Apostate Prophet, Sottomessi e sanguinari

The “No Compulsion in Islam” Lie – YouTube

00:10
hi everyone and welcome this is the
00:12
apostate prophet I have been very
00:15
inactive in the last two weeks that’s
00:17
because I had a few problems and I’m
00:19
sick as you might hear out of my voice
00:21
but I’m here again and I will be
00:23
continuing this work because we have a
00:25
lot of work to do and since I have seen
00:27
a lot of censorship online especially
00:29
here on YouTube recently I want to
00:31
increase my bluntness and my criticism
00:34
of Islam even more I want to talk about
00:36
a specific phrase that you’ll hear very
00:38
often from moderate Muslim apologists if
00:41
you’re hearing and reading a lot about
00:43
Islam you might have heard of the phrase
00:45
a lot there is no compulsion in religion
00:48
I’m sure almost everyone who’s watching
00:50
this video knows what I’m talking about
00:52
this phrase is very often brought up by
00:54
people very often in a wrong way without
00:57
even knowing their religion properly and
00:59
in the next moment they want to accuse
01:01
you of taking things out of context and
01:03
being Islamophobic the phrase comes from
01:05
the Quran in chapter 2 verse 256 it goes
01:10
there is no compulsion in religion the
01:12
right course has become clear from the
01:15
wrong so whoever disbelieves in
01:17
falsehood and believes in Allah has
01:19
grasped the most trustworthy handhold
01:21
with no break in it and allies hearing
01:24
and knowing some presented as let there
01:27
be no compulsion in religion but which
01:29
comes from the use of Ali translation of
01:31
the Quran but there shall be no or there
01:34
is no compulsion is a more accurate
01:36
translation of the first that’s what the
01:38
Quran says but what moderate Muslim
01:41
apologists want to say with this phrase
01:44
is that everyone is free under Islam to
01:47
practice their own religion and they can
01:49
believe whatever they want to believe no
01:51
one can be forced into Islam no one can
01:54
be fought because of their disbelief and
01:56
some even bring it to the extent that
01:58
there is no killing of apostates in
02:01
Islam because there is no compulsion in
02:03
Islam all of these things are either
02:05
completely or partially false and taken
02:08
out of context now I want to stay fair
02:11
but I want to make two points in advance
02:13
about this Quran first the first point
02:16
is that this Quran
02:17
first was revealed at a much earlier
02:19
time than later versus like the sward
02:21
first that order to fight the
02:23
non-muslims wherever you find them
02:25
it was also most likely revealed long
02:27
before verse 29 in chapter 9 where the
02:31
Quran orders the Muslims to fight all
02:33
those who don’t believe in Islam and to
02:35
force the jizya on them this is an
02:38
important point because if you are
02:39
familiar with Islamic theology you
02:41
should know that if some Quran verses
02:43
contradict each other in any way the
02:45
first that was revealed later is more
02:47
valid the Quran makes that very clear
02:49
the second point is that many scholars
02:52
even very important ones like even
02:54
kaffir said that a large number of
02:57
verses including the no compulsion first
02:59
have either been partially or completely
03:02
abrogated and practically replaced by
03:05
the order of fighting them the view that
03:07
the no compulsion first has been
03:09
completely abrogated is rather a very
03:12
traditionalist view but the view that it
03:14
has been partially abrogated is a rather
03:16
mainstream Islamic view it only makes
03:19
sense to think that the no compulsion
03:20
first has been at least partially
03:22
abrogated because there is a specific
03:24
ruling in Islam that we all know by now
03:27
the deme system and the jizya it always
03:32
feels so dirty saying this word and
03:34
reminds me of the smell of never mind I
03:36
have explained a VME system and pledges
03:38
year before in another video but to
03:40
summarize it very quickly then me refers
03:42
to non-muslim communities under Islam
03:44
because there is no such thing as
03:45
equality in Islam while the jizya refers
03:48
to protection money
03:49
yes protection money taken from
03:52
non-muslims under Islamic rule we see
03:55
clearly in Islamic Scripture and history
03:57
that Muslims are obligated to fight the
04:00
non-believers and to spread Islam by
04:03
campaigns when Muslims confront
04:05
non-muslim people in the cause of
04:07
expanding Islam they are obligated to
04:10
give the non-muslims three choices one
04:13
convert to Islam and there will be no
04:15
fighting to pay the jizya and you will
04:19
be subjected under Islamic rule as a
04:21
lesser people and well die if the
04:25
non-muslim group refuses to convert to
04:27
Islam or to come under Islamic rule and
04:30
pay protection
04:30
money they will be fought during this
04:33
battle they can still give up and can
04:34
either convert to Islam or become
04:36
subjugated this rule is based on Quran
04:39
chapter 9 verse 29 which was revealed in
04:43
Muhammad’s last times and it has also
04:46
clearly outlined in Muhammad’s words
04:48
where he also tells the Muslims to fight
04:51
in the name of Allah in the way of Allah
04:53
and fight against those who disbelieve
04:56
in Allah it’s very clear this comes to
04:58
no surprise because in another hadith
05:01
Muhammad said very clearly I have been
05:04
ordered to fight the people till they
05:06
say none has the right to be worshipped
05:08
but Allah and later in this hadith it
05:11
has also made clear again for all those
05:14
who have doubts that one has only the
05:16
same rights and obligations of a Muslim
05:18
if he becomes a Muslim as you can see in
05:21
this clearly detailed and explained
05:24
Islamic rule as you can see in this
05:26
clearly detailed and complete Islamic
05:29
rule the words there is no compulsion in
05:32
religion are not a promise of peace
05:34
there is no promise of peace in Islam
05:37
according to major Islamic scholars like
05:39
even kaffir no compulsion in religion
05:41
means that you can’t go to an individual
05:44
and at gunpoint force him to become a
05:47
Muslim but Islamic texts make a
05:49
difference between individuals and the
05:52
tribes or nations they belong to no
05:54
compulsion in religion does not mean
05:56
that Muslims can’t fight non-muslims and
05:59
subjugate them if that was the case
06:02
Muslims wouldn’t be able to spread Islam
06:05
and if you are familiar with history you
06:07
should know that from Mohammed to the
06:09
Ottomans caliphates used warfare to
06:12
spread Islam to fight non-muslims and
06:14
either convert them to Islam or to force
06:17
them to pay the jizya and be unequal
06:20
under the Islamic system for example
06:22
this is the early spread of Islam only
06:24
an idiot would believe all the nations
06:27
in the way of this expansion just gave
06:29
flowers to the Muslims and said come
06:31
please take our land this was also made
06:34
clear by later historian and respected
06:37
Islamic scholar even Halden who wrote in
06:40
his masterpiece ma kardama the following
06:42
words in the Muslim come
06:44
of the holy war is a religious duty
06:47
because of the universalism of the
06:49
Muslim mission and the obligation to
06:51
convert everybody to Islam inna by
06:53
persuasion or by force
06:55
therefore Caliphate and royal authority
06:58
are united in Islam so that the person
07:01
in charge can devote the available
07:03
strength to both of them at the same
07:05
time as you can see a Muslim a historian
07:08
an Islamic scholar casually explains
07:11
that in an Islamic system the ruler
07:14
controls the course of state and
07:15
religion and uses the force to spread
07:18
Islam by the sword even Halden is a very
07:21
respected historian of Islam and he
07:24
lives in the 14th century he had seen a
07:26
lot of caliphates before he wrote that I
07:28
have talked about the dimi system
07:30
applied to non-muslims under Islamic
07:32
rule before and I talked about the jizya
07:35
in both cases I explained that
07:37
non-muslims and Muslims don’t have equal
07:40
rights under Islam what’s also important
07:42
to note is that under Mohammed the deme
07:45
system in Tunisia were only applied to
07:48
Christians Jews Sabian’s and later to
07:51
the Austrians
07:52
that’s why fundamentalist Muslims view
07:54
the deme system and the jizya to be
07:56
applied only only to those groups other
07:59
groups can be fought and killed without
08:02
having such an option convert to Islam
08:04
or die so early Muslim caliphate did
08:07
indeed forcibly convert non-muslims or
08:10
exiled or enslaved them forcibly
08:13
converting here means that the opponents
08:15
didn’t have any choice but convert to
08:18
Islam or die and sorry but that’s the
08:20
definition of forcible conversion and
08:23
Muslims did that and that didn’t make
08:26
them non Muslims or not real Muslims
08:29
many fundamentalist Muslims of our time
08:31
that form large groups in specific
08:33
regions have the view that non-muslims
08:36
beside Jews and Christians can be fought
08:39
and killed the fate of Jews and
08:41
Christians is not much different they
08:43
can be fought and killed until they
08:45
accept to be subjugated by Islam that’s
08:48
exactly what the Islamic text preaches
08:50
that’s within the limits of Islamic
08:52
theology and it doesn’t make you a non
08:55
Muslim as you can see no component in
08:57
religion does not mean that everyone is
09:00
free to practice their own religion
09:01
freely that was never the case until the
09:04
Muslim world started to be westernized
09:06
and modernized by force one last point
09:10
that I want to make is that the killing
09:12
of apostates in Islam is in no way a
09:15
contradiction to no compulsion in
09:17
religion although moderate Muslims just
09:20
want to tell you so no compulsion in
09:22
Islam refers to the part of accepting
09:25
Islam of getting into Islam it has
09:28
nothing to do with renouncing and
09:30
abandoning Islam the vast majority of
09:32
Islamic scholars in history agree that
09:35
apostates deserved to be killed and
09:37
that’s very clear in multiple hadith
09:40
reported as directly spoken by Muhammad
09:43
the Prophet to make it very short you as
09:45
a non-muslim can’t be approached
09:48
individually and forced to convert to
09:50
Islam under Islamic rule you can still
09:53
be given the choice to be a slave to
09:55
Muslims but once you become a Muslim you
09:57
have to stay a Muslim otherwise you will
10:00
feel the mercy of Islam warmly
10:02
separating your head from the rest of
10:04
your body narrated by Abdullah a last
10:07
messenger said the blood of a Muslim who
10:09
confesses that none has the right to be
10:11
worshipped but Allah and that I am his
10:13
apostle cannot be shed except in three
10:16
cases in retaliation for murder a
10:19
married person who commits illegal
10:21
sexual intercourse and the one who
10:23
reverts from Islam and leaves the
10:26
Muslims very clear right so to summarise
10:29
it
10:29
you can’t forcibly convert an individual
10:32
to Islam but you can fight them you can
10:35
fight and kill them so they don’t have
10:37
any option but convert to Islam you can
10:40
subjugate religious groups take
10:42
protection money and treat them like
10:44
dirt if they want to join Islam
10:47
consequently they can to leave Islam any
10:49
more sincerely a religion of peace this
10:53
is why we need to go away from Islam as
10:55
far as possible and that’s why we need
10:57
to inform people about what Islam really
11:00
is and we need to work together in this
11:02
so that no Islamic rule can be allowed
11:05
near anywhere we live no revival of
11:08
Islam no
11:09
Islamic influence at all we need to
11:11
uphold a world of freedom not a world of
11:14
darkness in which Islam decides how you
11:17
live your life or if you live a life at
11:19
all
11:19
it is 2018 we don’t need Islam just the
11:23
way we don’t need slavery and human
11:25
sacrifice thanks for watching before I
11:28
let you go I have recently launched my
11:30
German channel where I will release
11:32
videos entirely in German and the first
11:34
video is already there so for all German
11:37
speakers that’s where we can spread the
11:38
message the link is below in a
11:40
description in the comment section
11:42
another announcement that I want to make
11:43
is that I will be on David woods channel
11:45
for an interview tomorrow for those who
11:47
haven’t seen it I he was on my channel
11:49
yesterday so make sure to join us
11:51
tomorrow on his channel if you want to
11:53
support my cause you can support me on
11:55
patreon with rewards in return the link
11:57
is below in a description thank you all
11:59
so much for any kind of support have a
12:02
great weekend
12:03
please protect your values and your
12:05
freedom stay away from Islam

References:

Here’s the link to the German channel: https://www.youtube.com/c/ApostateProphetDE

Autore:

La Dea Tutte mi ha inviato a combattere il demone dell'evanescenza, fin dalla pianura che non deve essere nominata

Rispondi

Inserisci i tuoi dati qui sotto o clicca su un'icona per effettuare l'accesso:

Logo di WordPress.com

Stai commentando usando il tuo account WordPress.com. Chiudi sessione /  Modifica )

Foto Twitter

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Twitter. Chiudi sessione /  Modifica )

Foto di Facebook

Stai commentando usando il tuo account Facebook. Chiudi sessione /  Modifica )

Connessione a %s...

Questo sito utilizza Akismet per ridurre lo spam. Scopri come vengono elaborati i dati derivati dai commenti.